fbpx Criticism | HowlRound Theatre Commons

Criticism

Here, you’ll find content about the art and practice of theatre criticism. Many pieces grapple with questions of how to diversify the field, making it more accessible for young people, queer folx, and critics of color. This section also contains all the pieces of criticism in the Journal, which we call “NewCrits.” NewCrits analyze productions and go beyond “thumbs up, thumbs down” reviews, placing the work(s) in question in a larger, broader context—whether that’s the context of the time or place it’s done in, the artists’ body of work, or its genre. Are you interested in writing a NewCrit? Check out our guidelines and best practices!

The Latest

On Between Two Knees, or About Other Futures
Essay
On Between Two Knees, or About Other Futures
by Sebastián Eddowes-Vargas
17 April 2024
Viewpoints for Achieving Authentic Representation of Roma Communities on Stage
Essay
Viewpoints for Achieving Authentic Representation of Roma Communities on Stage
by Tímea Éva Bogya, Márton Illés
27 March 2024
Should We Write Differently About Roma Theatre?
Essay
Should We Write Differently About Roma Theatre?
by Noémi Herczog, Éva Moharos
25 March 2024
Pulling a New Rabbit Out of an Old Hat
Essay

Pulling a New Rabbit Out of an Old Hat

The Tempest at American Repertory Theater

22 May 2014

Srila Nayak reviews the American Repertory Theater’s production of William Shakespeare’s The Tempest, and highlights how the production uses music, color-consious-casting, spectacle, and stage-magic.

Portrait of Carrie Robbins.
Carrie Robbins, from celebrated Broadway Costume Designer to Determined Off-Off Broadway Playwright
Essay

Carrie Robbins, from celebrated Broadway Costume Designer to Determined Off-Off Broadway Playwright

20 May 2014

Jonathan Mandell writes about the life of prolific costume designer Carrie Robbins, and her new ambitions as adaptor and playwright.

American Morrow
Essay

American Morrow

Jonathan Moscone and Lily Janiak in Conversation

18 May 2014

Lily Janiak and Artistic Director of Cal Shakes Jon Moscone talk about the impact of Janiak’s criticism of the play American Night at California Shakespeare Theater and the controversy it stirred.

The Love of the Nightingale in Washington, D.C.
Essay

The Love of the Nightingale in Washington, D.C.

15 May 2014

Patricia Davis reviews the Constellation Theatre's production of The Love of the Nightingale by Timberlake Wertenbaker

Tea bowl with the impression of a leaf.
Psychoanalysis and Breast Milk at the Boston Museum of Fine Arts
Essay

Psychoanalysis and Breast Milk at the Boston Museum of Fine Arts

13 May 2014

Allison Vanouse reviews a performance by Jeffrey Gibson and Patty Chang at Boston's Museum of Fine Arts, and responds to other critics of the piece.

The Controversy in Chicago Over the Critical Review of God’s Work
Essay

The Controversy in Chicago Over the Critical Review of God’s Work

9 May 2014

In accepting the single story that "God’s Work" does not belong in a downtown Chicago theater, do we contribute to the silencing of the voices of our youth? I believe "God’s Work" is just as worthy of embodiment on stage as "Our Class" or any other current Chicago production, regardless of the age of the ensemble members telling it.

A Man at Diva Fest
Essay

A Man at Diva Fest

Stuart Bousel Adapts Kristin Hersh’s Rat Girl

8 May 2014

Lily Janiak discusses the world premiere of Stuart Eugene Bousel's adaptation of Rat Girl, a memior by Kristin Hersh, lead singer of Throwing Muses.

Exemplary Youth Theater in Albany Park Theatre Project’s God’s Work
Essay

Exemplary Youth Theater in Albany Park Theatre Project’s God’s Work

6 May 2014

Dani Snyder-Young writes about the Chicago-based Albany Park Theatre Project, a youth theatre ensemble. She reviews APTP's 2014 remounted production of God's Work, at the Goodman Theatre.

A Tony Award.
Tony Snubs, Pulitzer Flubs, Theater Award Excitement
Essay

Tony Snubs, Pulitzer Flubs, Theater Award Excitement

1 May 2014

Jonathan Mandell looks at the phenomenon of "snubs" in theatre awards today and throughout history, touching on the complexities of nominating committees.

two actors onstage
What Happened When Critics Failed to Review My Latino Play?
Essay

What Happened When Critics Failed to Review My Latino Play?

30 April 2014

And although I’m proud of the production and of the nearly-all Latina/o creative team that gave Mariela en el Desierto an authentic voice, an issue arose as the last weekend of performances approached: No critics from the periodicals in the Atlanta area had attended or reviewed the show.

Photo from The Goat or Who Is Sylvia.
Should High Schoolers Perform The Goat, or Who is Sylvia?
Essay

Should High Schoolers Perform The Goat, or Who is Sylvia?

24 April 2014

Alice Stanley Jr. writes about an event she attended, responding to the suspension of an Arizona high school drama teacher that included Albee's who in his curriculum.

Photo from Bum Phillips All American.
Sex, Death, Marriage, Greed and Football
Essay

Sex, Death, Marriage, Greed and Football

Texas Playwright Kirk Lynn in New York

22 April 2014

Jonathan Mandell overviews five eclectic works by Texas playwright Kirk Lynn.

Making a Statement about Diversity at the Humana Festival of New American Plays
Essay

Making a Statement about Diversity at the Humana Festival of New American Plays

18 April 2014

Dani Snyder-Young writes about the intentional diversity she witnessed in five of the 2014 Humana Festival productions.

Nabil Al-Ra’ee and his daughter.
Death and Art in Palestine
Essay

Death and Art in Palestine

Nabil Al-Ra’ee and The Freedom Theatre

15 April 2014

Patricia Davis writes about The Freedom Theatre in Palestine, focusing on its controversial work with youth and its history, which includes the assassination of their founder.

Photo from The Tank Man.
What Chimerica Tells Us About the Photograph
Essay

What Chimerica Tells Us About the Photograph

14 April 2014

Based on an actual photograph, the main action of Lucy Kirkwood’s play is an American photojournalist’s unyielding quest to unlock the mystery of a photograph taken by him during the 1989 student revolution and military crackdown in Tiananmen Square. In the photograph in question a slender man, who goes on to be labeled the “Tank Man,” stands in front of a line of military tanks rolling into the Square. While it is something of a truism that the theater is, as a character in Don Quixote says, “the mirror of human life” sometimes theater can serve as a path-breaking reflection on another art form.

Performing Age
Essay

Performing Age

Mallory Catlett’s This Was The End

10 April 2014

Bertie Ferdman reviews Mallory Catlett's adaption of Uncle Vanya featuring actors in their sixties and seventies.

Photo from The Complete & Condensed Stage Directions of Eugene O’Neill, Volume 1.
New York Neo-Futurists
Essay

New York Neo-Futurists

An Interview with Christopher Andrew Loar

8 April 2014

Bess Rowen interviews Christopher Andrew Loar of the New York Neo-Futurists, creator/director of The Complete & Condensed Stage Directions of Eugene O’Neill.

event banner ad
Perspectives in Theatre Criticism: A Keynote by Lauren Gunderson livestreaming from Humana Festival of New American Plays
Video

Perspectives in Theatre Criticism: A Keynote by Lauren Gunderson livestreaming from Humana Festival of New American Plays

Thursday 3 April 2014
Louisville, KY, United States

Humana Festival of New American Plays at Actors Theatre of Louisville presented Perspectives in Theatre Criticism livestreamed on the global, commons-based peer-produced HowlRound TV network at howlround.tv on Thursday 3 April at 11 a.m. PDT/ 1 p.m. CDT / 2 p.m. EDT / 18:00 GMT / 7 p.m. BST (London).

Two actors fight on stage in a boxing ring in Rocky.
The Broadway Effect in Rocky, Aladdin, Les Miz
Essay

The Broadway Effect in Rocky, Aladdin, Les Miz

3 April 2014

Jonathan Mandell looks at reocurring devices and techniques of spectacle in Broadway productions.

Photo from Forgiveness: A Theatrical Poem.
The Mystery of Forgiveness at the Modern Times Stage Company
Essay

The Mystery of Forgiveness at the Modern Times Stage Company

1 April 2014

Matt McGeachy writes about Modern Times Stage Company's Forgiveness: A Theatrical Poem, an intense movement piece exploring the dialetic between forgiveness and forgetting. 

Amnesia
Essay

Amnesia

A Jewish Perspective on Anti-Latino Prejudice

27 March 2014

Alice Stanley Jr. discusses her experience at a workshop of Ariel Luckey's solo performance Amnesia, and the talkback which followed.

Race & Real Estate in Next Theatre’s Luck of the Irish by Kirsten Greenidge
Essay

Race & Real Estate in Next Theatre’s Luck of the Irish by Kirsten Greenidge

25 March 2014

Dani Snyder-Young reviews the (now closed) Next Theatre Company production of Kirsten Greenidge’s Luck of the Irish in the context of Evanston, Illinois

Photo from HIR.
The Theater Was Ours
Essay

The Theater Was Ours

Next Gen Nights and Hir at the Magic Theatre

21 March 2014

 looks at how Magic Theatre's initative for young theatre-goes went beyond a discount, and how the premiere of Taylor Mac's Hir at the Magic complemented their earlier production of Buried Child.

Photo from Kung Fu.
The Life of Bruce Lee on Stage
Essay

The Life of Bruce Lee on Stage

18 March 2014

W.M. Akers looks at David Henry Hwang's Kung Fu, a bio-play about the life and career of Bruce Lee

Photo from a performance in the BCAP.
University Theater in Boston
Essay

University Theater in Boston

The Classical Experimental

13 March 2014

Allison Vanouse continues her look at productions from university students in Boston. In this post she reviews Steven Berkoff's adaptation of Kafka's Metamorphosis, directed by Elaine Vaan Hogue