fbpx Criticism | HowlRound Theatre Commons

Criticism

Here, you’ll find content about the art and practice of theatre criticism. Many pieces grapple with questions of how to diversify the field, making it more accessible for young people, queer folx, and critics of color. This section also contains all the pieces of criticism in the Journal, which we call “NewCrits.” NewCrits analyze productions and go beyond “thumbs up, thumbs down” reviews, placing the work(s) in question in a larger, broader context—whether that’s the context of the time or place it’s done in, the artists’ body of work, or its genre. Are you interested in writing a NewCrit? Check out our guidelines and best practices!

The Latest

Essay
Black Survival and Cyclical Fate in Hang Time
by Ciaran Short
4 June 2026
Essay
On a Theatrical Pilgrimage to See Carolina Bianchi and Cara de Cavalo's Chapter II: The Brotherhood
by Amanda L. Andrei
6 April 2026
Essay
How The Last Country Amplifies Stories of Immigration and Belonging in South Africa
by Tonderai Chiyindiko
4 February 2026
Two people dressed in traditional Indian clothing looking at a little brown cart.
Essay
11 December 2025

Mrichchakatikam (The Little Clay Cart) is known globally, but it had never been performed in Koodiyattam until this year. Shereen Saif reflects on G. Venu’s adaptation of the classic play, which radically condensed the original and took creative liberties with plot, casting, and tradition.

A screenshot of a zoom call.
Essay
4 December 2025

Since 2020, the BIPOC Critics Lab has trained dozens of emerging critics in craft of criticism. In this reflection on the joy, labor, and creativity that goes into running the program, José Solis surfaces lessons from the lab’s path thus far.

event poster for critics in conversation.
Video

A Conversation with Honorees of the 2025 Edward Medina Prize for Excellence in Cultural Criticism, Citlali Pizarro and Christian Lewis

Saturday 8 November 2025
New York City

This year, 2025 honoree Citlali Pizarro and 2024 honoree Christian Lewis engage in an enlightening conversation about the state of theater, navigating careers in arts journalism, their pathways to the arts, the importance of fresh perspectives, and more. 

Four people in tropical clothes smiling.
Essay
25 September 2025

In Ryan “Oki” Naka’s hands The Golden Girls are reinvented as “The Golden Gays”: four queer Hawaiians navigating middle age in Waikiki Beach. Through love, friendship, and resistance, Nguyễn Minh Tiến writes, the characters in Ryan Okinaka's The Golden Gays overcome their challenges together.

A row of actors standing on stage with a photo of Hitler behind them on the screen.
Essay
22 September 2025

Lass uns die Welt vergessen: Volksoper 1938 stages Austria’s fascist past, reckoning with the ghosts of Nazism and their legacies. For Jordan Schildcrout, the docudrama-metamusical becomes an opportunity to interrogate Austria’s history—and to imagine the future of the United States.

A man in the center of an empty room.
Essay
4 September 2025

Several characters are played by one performer in I’m Assuming You Know David Greenspan. In an analysis that spans from ancient Greece to contemporary Russia, Arseniy Fariatiev argues that the play does the opposite for the director, splitting directorial labor across several production roles.

Three women on stage holding hands.
Essay
28 August 2025

For almost forty years, Real Women Have Curves has pulled audiences in with its story of Latine women in a sewing factory taking charge of their own destinies. Carlos Morton traces the story’s path from play to film to Broadway musical, affirming the power at its core.

A person sitting in a dimly lit room holding a puppet of an old man.
Essay
27 August 2025

How can a life be organized? What authority should an archive hold? Dani Lamorte explores questions like these that propel B Kleymeyer’s As Others Have Before, an account of a sculptor’s life and the claims the living have on the stories of the dead.

A blue blob with a person in the middle.
Essay
18 August 2025

“If your body is a portal, where does it lead?” This question led the creation of Paradise Portals, an immersive performance and dance party featuring Baltimore-area trans and queer artists. Laura Grothaus captures some of these artists’ answers, which span the celebration, transformation, ecology, and even escape.

A person dressed in masquerade attire singing out dramatically.
Essay
30 July 2025

Parrots at the Pagoda imagines an afterworld where parrots guide Puerto Rican drag performer Johnny Rodriguez through memories of his life. In this journey, Citlali Pizarro writes, the transformation of death and life into memory illuminates a queer Latinx theatricality that celebrates itself against erasure.

An actor in a red robe and white mask in a stairway with another actor in a black backless dress.
Essay
21 July 2025

Teatru Malta’s 1881 infused immersive theatre with game design, all in a dark, castle-like setting. After witnessing 1881 and other Maltese performances, critic Jonathan Mandell is left questioning the evolving forms and definitions of immersive theatre.

A group of people dancing on stage.
Essay
17 July 2025

“Add Theater to Taste” was the recent theme of the annual Iloilo Theater Festival in the Philippines. Heritage language learner Amanda L. Andrei shares how the shows used food to explore deeper social issues and how her experience in the audience connected her more deeply to her roots.

A promotional graphic for Daughters of Lorraine.
Podcast
27 May 2025

In today’s episode, Leticia and Jordan discuss the Canadian premiere of A Strange Loop—a co-production between The Musical Stage Company, Soulpepper Theatre, Crow’s Theatre, and TO Live. They re-appraise the musical’s impact in today’s sociopolitical climate.

A group of people in nude leotards and makeup.
Essay
19 May 2025

Ann Liv Young’s Marie Antoinette at Under the Radar sparked a lot of controversy, namely for its treatment of the performers. Carmi recounts the theatrical experience that was unlike any they’ve had before—which was also true for the performers.

A stage screen that projects a small puppetry scene.
Essay
30 April 2025

The La MaMa Puppet Festival, which brought three weeks of puppet performances to New York City. The productions, writes Lucy Haskell, moved the material world to help us reconsider our own relationships to the worlds inside and around us.

A promotional graphic for Daughter's of Lorraine.
Podcast
29 April 2025

Jordan and Leticia interview arts journalist and playwright Kelundra Smith about the cultural landscape of theatre criticism and what it means to tell authentic Black stories.

A person sitting behind a laptop and four people sitting in a row behind them in a classroom like stage set.
Essay
2 April 2025

In Jonathan Spector’s Eureka Day, a mumps outbreak draws private school parents into heated debates about vaccination requirements. Dr. Nisha Sajnani, co-director of the Jameel Arts and Health Lab, positions the play as a much-needed salve to one of the most polarizing public health issues of our time.

Two people standing in bright lighting with a black background, one with their hand raised and the other looking up where the hand is pointing.
Essay
26 March 2025

Josephine Lee discusses the casting and performance choices of the 2024 Gypsy revival—from Audra McDonald’s Rose to a Chinese waitress in yellowface—to consider what they signal about the complex histories of racial performance that continue to influence theatre today.

Three people dressed in pink aprons and hats present a pink vat to someone dressed as a manager on stage.
Essay
12 March 2025

How do you write a union play that doesn’t end in everyone yelling “Strike!”? Abby Schoering explores one answer to this question offered by Gwen Kingston’s Café Utopia, which engaged Notch Theatre’s community-responsive methods, verbatim interludes, and enough juicery puns to keep the laughs coming.

Actors in bright costumes pose onstage.
Essay
19 February 2025

In ProyectoTEATRO’s Cabarex 2: RevoLUZiones, history is funnier, sexier, and messier than a textbook ever could be. Khristián Méndez Aguirre writes about the production’s queer, devised cabaret take on Latinx culture and history.

A woman is behind a music stand gesture's passionately.
Essay
3 February 2025

Ghost Forest grapples with the climate crisis playing out through sea level rise that impacts forests of the Eastern Bay in Maryland. Taylor Leigh Lamb discusses the way the play’s ecological approach extended into new play development process that supported the art, the artists, and the surrounding community.

event poster for celebrating PAJ and Bonnie Maranca.
Video

A Celebration of the Publication of the Final Issue of PAJ: A Journal of Performance and Art and its Co-Founder and Editor Bonnie Marranca

Monday 9 December 2024
New York City

For more than four decades, PAJ has explored innovative works in theatre, performance art, dance, video, writing, technology, sound, and music through wide-ranging cultural dialogue and historical context.  To honor the important contributions of PAJ, the Segal Center hosted conversation with Bonnie Marranca and Segal Center’s director Frank Hentschker.

 Members and participants of Spit Dat Academy at the District of Columbia Central Detention Facility wearing orange jumpsuits pose for a photo.
Essay
20 November 2024

Citlali Pizarro draws on her own experience working with incarcerated poets, and learnings from the film Sing Sing about Sing Sing Correctional Facility’s Rehabilitation Through the Arts program, to explore how common narratives about creating theatre in prison fall short, and what theatremakers must understand instead.

event poster for Critics in Conversation.
Video

A Conversation with Winners of the Edward Medina Prize for Excellence in Cultural Criticism, Christian Lewis and Gloria Oladipo

Saturday 9 November 2024
New York City

An enlightening conversation about the state of theater, navigating careers in arts journalism, their pathways to the arts, the importance of fresh perspectives, and more.

3 actors sit in a small inflatable tub onstage.
Essay
30 October 2024

Amanda L. Andrei uses an understanding of hapa identity to explore the liminal and voluminous identities at play in David Johann Kim’s Pang Spa—both onstage and off.

Subscribe to HowlRound

Sign up for our daily, weekly, or quarterly emails so you never miss the latest theatre conversations.

Sign me up

Support HowlRound

We fundraise to keep all our programs free and open and to pay our contributors. Thank you to all who make our work possible!

Donate today